Money Maker PumpThis is a featured page

Authors:Phoebe (Yat) Wu and Sheila Doshi
email: ymwu@ucsd.edu,
svdoshi@ucsd.edu
msn: phoebe_bps@hotmail.com



What is a MoneyMaker Hip Pump?
Money Maker Pump - Design for  Development
helping farmers out of poverty...
Money Maker Pump - Design for  Development
The MoneyMaker Hip Pump is a micro irrigation technology introduced my the non-profit organization, KickStart. Since 1996, KickStart has been the leader in developing and marketing irrigation technologies for Africa.

As the title suggests, this is a pump made to make money! $$
And who doesn't want that? In the 21st century, we cannot just give money to underdeveloped countries in hopes that they will get out of poverty. They need to make their own, and all they need is a little help.

And it's so simple....Instead of manually pumping with your armsMoney Maker Pump - Design for  Development, which is very tiring, a stepping motion is used.

With the hip swinging of the stepping motion comes the name 'hip
pump'. :)

It costs about
$34, and pays for itself in only 3-4 months of use!
Money Maker Pump - Design for  Development

TechnologySummary:
The MoneyMaker Hip Pump is a light and easy-to-use pressure pump that can irrigate water from a depth of six meters and lifting it to a height of thirteen meters above the water source. On average, users of the Hip Pump have increased their net farm income and tripled their initial investment after three or four months, and is amongst the quickest and most cost-effective ways to help people out of poverty.



Dilemmas concerning the rich and the poor:
Money Maker Pump - Design for  Development
Funny? Sad? Ironic?

Ever since industrialization, there has been an ongoing growth in the gap between the rich and the poor throughout the world. The idea of capitalism, where investors desire to have the maximum output (profit) with the minimum input (cheap labor), ultimately benefits the rich and further devalues the poor. In the modern world, the West, which is no longer defined geographically, becomes a concept or ideology applying to anyone that lives the 'Western way of life'. The West represents the rich and the powerful. To define their sense of authority over the rest of the world, names such as 'third world' or 'under developing' countries, 'primitive' or 'indigenous' people, are formed. The poor learn to accept and compare themselves to the rich and dream of having the same excess and prestige, which helps construct their inferior identity.
Ironically, elites decide to create high-paying job positions to study exactly that, the relationship between the rich and the poor. With collections of researched data and statistics, is the UN actually forming plans and helping the underdeveloped?

Are the UN, NGOs, non-profit organizations actually helping?

Very questionable. The problem is that people with wonderful intentions sometimes seem to overlook cultural diversities. They have the tendency to impose Western standards or ideologies onto an undeveloped place or community, without considering their existing, and probably contradicting traditions.
Also, the idea of a donation is nice, but is it really helping them to develop?
Donation might cause the poor to be dependent on constant aid from the government or other organizations, instead of being motivated to work for their own money and food.
That is exactly why Kickstart has decided to sell their MoneyMaker Hip Pumps instead of providing them without a cost.


The Introduction
:
Money Maker Pump - Design for  Development
The Moneymaker Hip Pump is introduced to different regions in Africa, mainly in Kenya, Tanzania, and Mali. It was invented by Martin Fisher and Nick Moon from the San Francisco based non-profit company called KickStart. The company has already sold 63,000 pumps and generated an estimated number of $45 million in profits and wages. According to statistics, there are about 1.1 billion people in the world that live on less than $1 a day, about 70% of them are subsistence rural farmers working with unproductive land. By irrigation from the water tables, this technology comes to the rescue by providing consistent water source for the farmers. Its capacity to generate profit would also create an incentive for those who are unemployed or impoverished to take on farming.

Money Maker Pump - Design for  Development:
The aim behind this product is “to create dignity rather than dependency and to leave in a place a sustainable and dynamic private sector.” (Fisher) In an interview, the creators were asked why, with the low cost of $34 for a pump, does the company not supply them to the poor for free. Their reasoning is that a poor person's basic need is to make money. They have to earn enough to purchase this pump, which motivates them to kick start a new life with their own effort, not relying on free things from the NGOs. This way they are working and putting themselves in the market to improve life status and gradually work their way up the hierarchy to provide more for their families. Starting from barely meeting basic needs, to having extra income, is a huge step of development.

SocialAspect:
Many farmers had problems with the inconsistent weather, they were often battling with lack of rainfall and droughts in unproductive lands. The irrigation pump allows them to have consistent water throughout the year, helping the crops and providing more consistent income for the families.


Watch this video by Maasai rap artist Mr. Ebbo to learn more about this life-changing technology. It's called "Don't Wait For the Rain":




As you can see, this irrigation technology has already been widely accepted and promoted in Africa. People are catching on to the ways that this technology not only helps them with the problem of a lack of water, but also helps them earn a living and improve their happiness in all aspects of their life.

EconomicAspect:
Since the farmers can repay the cost of the pump within three to four months, it can only mean profit with the increase of production. The increase of revenues will increase the farmer's income, then he or she can either consume more seeds and land, or save the money for investment or other purposes. Gradually with the growth from subsistence farming to commercial agriculture, more workers or labor force maybe needed. Farmers become employers and create job opportunities. With their extra income, they can also provide education for their children so they can join the skilled and elited, and have better job positions in the future. Moving up the social stratification system.


Money Maker Pump - Design for  Developmentproduction=Money Maker Pump - Design for  Developmentrevenues(after debt/cost of pump)=Money Maker Pump - Design for  Developmentincome=Money Maker Pump - Design for  Developmentconsumption OR Money Maker Pump - Design for  Developmentsaving


=Money Maker Pump - Design for  Developmentinvestment=Money Maker Pump - Design for  Developmentlabor force=Money Maker Pump - Design for  Developmentjob opportunities=Money Maker Pump - Design for  Developmenteducation=Money Maker Pump - Design for  DevelopmentMoney Maker Pump - Design for  Development


EnvironmentalAspect:
-noiseless and does not cost pollution
-does not harm environment
-made of steel
-exercise your body while breathing fresh air
-purifies your soul? Amazing!


CaseStudies:
1) In the case of Mr. Mururi of Kenya, he was landless and had a family with three children. At first he worked in the city and the money was barely enough to support his family. Then he was introduced to the MoneyMaker Hip Pump by a local store, feeling inspired, Mr Mururi and his wife rented a small plot of land and made enough money in two months to buy the pump. After regaining the $34, it was money making time! They bought more land and plan to invest in more in the future.

2) There was also another successful case in Tanzania where Mr. Sway, a coffee farmer, out of desperation with severe drought, purchased the MoneyMaker Pump and now he has an additional small vegetable garden for domestic use and enough water to water his cattle, and hire four other workers to help him with his farming. He also mentioned that his extra income will allow him to put his children in universities where they can be educated. Another success!




Money Maker Pump - Design for  Development
theevolution ofDesign:

The Design:

The design of the KickStart's Super MoneyMaker hip irrigation pump has evolved a little over the years. It started out as a $110 model that was a bit larger and bulkier to use. It used a similar mechanism as the one currently in use with a piston and a handle to pump the water. There were two pedals for the operator to push up and down with their feet, similar to a stair climber that we see in gyms, while they held onto a handle. The user stands on top of the pedals and holds onto the upright handlebars, and power the pump with a stepping motion. The water is then pushed through a hose. A second person is needed to splash water onto crops. There is no electricity or fuel required and although it required physical effort, it is much better than the old way of getting water to crops. This usually included getting buckets from the closest body of water or well and manually carrying the water to the crops. It was also approximately 3 feet high and about a foot wide. The maximum pumping rate was 1.5 liters per second and could irrigate up to 2 acres in 8 hours. The pump could be operated by either one adult or two children at a time. It could pump water up to 14 meters underground and up to 150 meters on flat ground.

An Improvement:
Money Maker Pump - Design for  Development
KickStart then designed another pump that was even cheaper at $55. The design was less bulky, at about only 3 feet tall and very narrow and had see-saw type pedals and a handle and piston to pump the water. The operator would stand on the pedal and go back and forth from side to side to pump the water. The maximum pumping rate was one liter per second and could irrigate up to 1.5 acres. It is designed to be used by one adult. The maximum height that the water could be reached and pumped was also about 13 meters or 43 feet. This pump is $40 less but has only a few setbacks from the first irrigation pump.
KickStart's newest irrigation pump, the one analyzed, is the MoneyMaker Hip Pump which is approximately 32 inches high, 14 inches wide, and 27 inches deep. It is made of mild steel, PVC piping, and high density polyethylene. The upside to the pump is that the pump's mechanisms can be replaced by hand with no tools required. The parts of the pump are easily found as local stores where the pump was initially purchased.


Methodology and Elements of the Design

KickStart's methodology behind the design and use of a pump was to create a lightweight, affordable, and easy-to-use irrigation pump. Another factor that was key was that is had to have parts that were easily and fully replaceable from a local store, without the use of tools. It needed to reach underground a substantial amount in order to get water to very dry areas. The hip pump is also easier to use with less strain on the muscles than the original pumps because it uses the swiveling of the hips to power the movement instead of calves and quadriceps.
This design is ideal for the environments in Africa. Because these are introduced in areas that are rural and poor, the design needed to cost little to make so that the price of the pump was also low and affordable. Martin Fisher and Nick Moon’s approach to the development and distribution of this product was that it was not to be given away to farmers. It needed to be affordable enough so that the would be able to buy it themselves. This way, they are more likely to use and appreciate the technology and maintain the pump. Also here would be no patronage or favoritism, and will be available to all who wants to spend the initial $34.
Not only was this equipment supposed to be directly useful in improving irrigation in drought ridden areas, it was going to be very useful in creating a business, employment, and income. This was essential in improving the lives of these rural workers. Since this tool does rely on human power, it must be ergonomic and safe. The designers have achieved this by allowing its users to use their body weight and the largest muscles. Martin Fisher says “While it looks like a hand pump, it is operated using a hip and leg motion rather than just your arms. Thus it can be operated for a long time without tiring …”.
Another methodology behind the development is the ease of transport and storage. The pump is light and small enough to be carried back from a farm to home by foot or bicycle. The ease of maintenance and use is essential as well. The use of the MoneyMaker pump is simple and intuitive with no training needed, just simple instructions. The conditions of these areas in which they will be in use are ones in rural rough conditions. The pump is very durable and can be used in very hot conditions.
EconomicallyStable

On average this hip pump has increased net farm income by over $125, tripling the initial investment of the $34 pump in a few months. It is economically feasible to sell these pumps, because it is from a for profit company who has already distributed 45,000 pumps that are currently in use by poor farmers. One of the developers of the pump said that it was essential that these pumps were simply not just given away for free because then farmers would not appreciate them and maintain them. Also, if there was no market for these pumps, there would be no suppliers and stores to sell them. Without a supply chain, repairing these pumps would be impossible without a place to buy parts. Also the people selling these pumps in Africa are getting a profit by having them in their stores. As long as there is a demand for the product, then there will be profits to be made.

CulturallyStable

The design of these pumps has been created with the culture of the people using them in mind. Many people in rural regions in Africa work barefoot because they prefer to and because shoes are not a necessity or available. The pump is safe and can efficiently be used barefoot or even with sandals on. Also, even though the pump requires a swaying motion of the hips, the motion has been minimized keeping in mind that many East African women see this movement as being provocative.

EnvironmentallyStable

Another problem that has gripped these third world countries in Asia and Africa is energy efficiency. They have the potential of exhaust the already depleting energy supply, and introducing technology that requires energy not only increases another need for a resource that is not readily available, it would also add to the existing problem. Therefore, the design needed to only use human power with no other outside energy, as well as not adding to pollution. Also, the machine is very efficient in converting human power to mechanical power. Also, many are worried that the already small water sources will be further depleted, but because they are only human powered, they will have little affect on the shallow aquifers.

Benefits to Society

The pump has allowed farmers to grow more sustainable cash crops like fruits and vegetables rather than lentils and beans. This is very important since most of these economies that need the pump work on cash. There have already been 23,000 new wage jobs created along with $37 million per year in new profits and wages generated by using these pumps. This has also created a way for women to work in the fields and help irrigate crops. Over half of the pumps in use are operate by women entrepreneurs.

The manufacturers that are producing these pumps are also benefiting from non giving these away for free. With more money going into public works projects like these, there is room, time, and money for improvement. With the first pump introduced in the mid-90s from KickStart, they have already improved and lowered the cost of these pumps four times in a decade and there is more room for innovation and improvement. Currently, an Oilseed press has been made to crush seeds like sunflower seeds into oil and animal feed to sustain a farmer's income even more.
Recommendations to the Existing Design
The design and implementation of the product are very ideal for the demographics it is being introduced in, mainly in rural parts of Africa and has the great potential of being used in Asia. Even though the actual use of the technology had no detriment to the environment itself, the manufacturing of the product involves PVC that has been said to damage the environment. In the vinyl lifecycle there are very large quantities of hazardous organochlorine by-products that are formed accidentally and released into the environment. These by products accumulate and stay in the environment and their toxicity can lead to health hazards even in very low doses.
To make this product even better, we would suggest that there be another plastic or material that serves the same purpose as PVC (light, flexible, and durable) that poses less of a threat to the environment.

Research Links:
Embassy Magazine Article
an NPR Broadcast
http://other90.cooperhewitt.org/Design/moneymaker-hip-pump
http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,1196420,00.html
http://www.bdafrica.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=2481&Itemid=5811
http://tanzania.usembassy.gov/pr_03022006.html
http://www.kickstart.org/tech/technologies/micro-irrigation.html
www.humanitarianinfo.org/sumatra/reliefrecovery/livelihood/docs/doc/KickstartIrrigationPumpsPresentation.pdf
http://www.healthybuilding.net/pvc/ThorntonPVCSummary.html


phoebewuuu
phoebewuuu
Latest page update: made by phoebewuuu , Feb 21 2008, 4:43 PM EST (about this update About This Update phoebewuuu Edited by phoebewuuu

4 words added
4 words deleted

view changes

- complete history)
Keyword tags: None
More Info: links to this page
There are no threads for this page.  Be the first to start a new thread.