Medicine Cold Box: Engineering World HealthThis is a featured page

Also: The Engineering Design Process

Group Members: Sneha Borikar, Sarah Bowen, Grace Chao, Nikhil Karmarkar, Sarah Smock

Steps 1 and 2: Identifying a Need and Defining the Problem

(taken from EWH website)
Medicine Cold Box: Engineering World Health - Design for  DevelopmentThere are many substances that must be kept cold in a hospital. Vaccines are the best known. For this reason, most health care facilities have at least one refrigerator. However, these cold boxes are typically concentrated in one part of the hospital, perhaps the blood bank. A subset of substances are sometimes needed on very short notice, far from theMedicine Cold Box: Engineering World Health - Design for  Development refrigerator. For example, oxytocin (used to contract the uterus after delivery) is unpredictably needed on short notice. Or, they may be required in very remote areas, where they must be carried by hand. Having no access to refrigeration, but knowing the need for the substances, many facilities simply leave a vial of the substance on the counter or exposed to heat and hope that it does not loose its potency. What is needed is a refrigerator of very small volume. It should be sufficient to store one days worth of the chemical (perhaps 5 ml) without the need for electricity or, preferably, any outside fuel. The cavity should be able to be maintained at about 10 degrees C for 12 hours. It could require shaking, cranking, solar, a hot piece of charcoal or any other non-electric fuel source.
Relevant Additional Specifications
Cost: <$100 in quantities of 500

Step 3: Conducting and Narrowing Research


Constraints and Specifications
ConstraintSpecification
should withstand drop from 6 ft.durability
1 cubic meterportable size
no more than 6lbsportable weight
none, standard partsminimal maintenance/cost req'd
no more than $100 when made in 500minimal production cost
can withstand 120F, can withstand humidity of 100% weather-resistant
can cool to under 10C, cooling
can cool within 30 minutesfast
no harm to usershuman safety
no harm or toxic chemicalsenvironmental safety
no toxic chemicals to medicinenon-contaminant
no outside electrical sourcenon-electric
must have efficiency above 50%efficient

Step 4: Finding alternative solutions


Figure 1. Schematic of Thermoelectric Operation
Medicine Cold Box: Engineering World Health - Design for  Development

Figure 2. Schematic of Heat Flow and Components
Medicine Cold Box: Engineering World Health - Design for  Development


Schematic of Absorptive Refrigeration
Medicine Cold Box: Engineering World Health - Design for  Development

Step 5: Analyzing possible solution



Properties of Design

Rank
Weight
1TE
Weighted Value 2ABS Weighted
Value
3STD Weighted
Value
Cooling Ability 1 10 4.3 42.5 4.25 42.5 3.8 37.5
Cost 2 10 4.3 42.5 2 20 2 20
Size 3 10 5 50 2.25 22.5 2 20
Weight 4 10 4.8 47.5 1.75 17.5 1.5 15
Energy source 5 8 2.8 22 4 32 2.8 22
Human safety 6 8 4.3 34 2.75 22 3 24
Durability 7 7 4.3 29.75 2.25 15.75 2 14
Standard parts 8 7 3.8 26.25 1.75 12.25 2.5 17.5
Maintenance 9 5 4 19 2 9 2.3 10.5
Efficiency 10 4 3.5 15 2.5 10.5 2.5 10.5
Environmental safety 11 3 3.5 10.5 2.75 8.25 2.8 8.25
Ease of use 12 2 4 8 3.75 7.5 3.5 7
Human input 13 1 3 3 4.25 4.25 2.8 2.75
Total of weighted values 350 224 209

Step 6: Presenting the product


Medicine Cold Box: Engineering World Health - Design for  Development
Medicine Cold Box: Engineering World Health - Design for  Development
Medicine Cold Box: Engineering World Health - Design for  Development


DerekLomas
DerekLomas
Latest page update: made by DerekLomas , Apr 29 2008, 12:32 PM EDT (about this update About This Update DerekLomas Moved from: public wiki - DerekLomas

No content added or deleted.

- complete history)
Keyword tags: None
More Info: links to this page
There are no threads for this page.  Be the first to start a new thread.